icon
30 min read
icon
Daniel Weltin

Jones Act and Maintenance and Cure: A Seaman's Guide

1. Start here: the first days after an injury at sea

If you work on a vessel and you were hurt or fell ill in the service of the ship, federal maritime law gives you rights that most land workers do not have. What you do in the first days protects them.

  1. Get medical care first. Tell the captain or mate you need a doctor. Your employer owes you medical care ("cure") even if no one was at fault.
  2. Report the injury in writing. Note the date, time, place on the vessel, what you were doing, and who saw it. Keep a copy or a photo of the report.
  3. Write down what happened while it is fresh: weather and sea state, the equipment involved, how many crew were on watch, any orders you were given.
  4. Take photos of the place you were hurt, broken gear, your injuries. Save the names and phone numbers of crew who saw it.
  5. Keep every receipt and record: medical bills, pharmacy, mileage, and your rent, mortgage, utilities and food costs at home. They set your maintenance rate (Chapter 5).
  6. Be careful with statements and papers. You do not have to give a recorded statement to an insurance adjuster. Do not sign a release, settlement or "final" paperwork before a maritime lawyer reads it.
  7. Mind the clock. Most claims for an injury at sea must be filed within three years (Chapter 12). Evidence and witnesses scatter much sooner, as crews change and vessels sail.
  8. Call a maritime lawyer early. A free call can tell you whether you count as a seaman, what your company owes you now, and what to avoid.

Not sure you are a seaman? Chapter 3 explains the test. If you work on the docks rather than on a vessel, see our Longshore guide.

2. A thousand years of sea law: from Norse ship-levies to the Jones Act

The rights you have today as a seaman are among the oldest in the law. The rule that a ship must care for a sailor hurt or taken ill in its service was written down more than 800 years ago, and American courts still apply it.

Ancient Mediterranean. Roman law borrowed a rule from the seafaring island of Rhodes: when cargo is thrown overboard to save a ship in a storm, everyone whose goods were saved shares the loss. This "Rhodian law of jettison" survives in Emperor Justinian's Digest (Book 14, Title 2), compiled in the 6th century AD. It records an emperor's reply: "I am lord of the world, but the law is lord of the sea." The same idea, now called "general average," is still part of maritime law.

The Norse and Viking age. Norway's early laws organized the coast for sea power. The Gulathing law, from an assembly probably founded around 930 and written down by about 1100, divided the coast into ship districts (skipreiður). Each had to supply a levy ship (leiðangr) with crew and provisions for the king's fleet. Norway's town and trading-place law (Bjarkøy law) began mostly as sea and trade law, and a seafarers' law for trading voyages (Farmannalǫg) accompanied King Magnus the Lawmender's Town Law of 1276. We have found no source showing that these Norse laws required care for sick or injured sailors; that rule, as we know it, enters the written record in the Rolls of Oléron.

The Rolls of Oléron (late 1100s). Judgments of the maritime court on the island of Oléron, off France's Atlantic coast, became the sea law of the Atlantic wine trade. Tradition, dating to a 1647 account, credits Eleanor of Aquitaine with recording them and King Richard I with bringing them to England; historians treat that story with caution. Two articles are the ancestors of your rights today:

  • Article 6: a mariner wounded in the service of the ship "shall be cured and provided for at the costs and charges of the said ship."
  • Article 7: a mariner who falls sick in the ship's service is to be put ashore, given lodging, light, food and an attendant, and paid his full wages, less the costs the master spent on him.

Wisby and the Hanseatic League. The sea laws of Visby, on the Baltic island of Gotland, and the ordinances of the German Hanseatic towns repeated the rule: a sick seaman put ashore "shall be fed, as he was aboard, and have somebody to look after him there" (Wisby, art. 19).

The Consolato del Mare. A collection of Mediterranean sea customs from Barcelona, first printed in 1494, governed trade across the Mediterranean.

America: Justice Story and "wards of the admiralty" (1823). In Harden v. Gordon, 11 F. Cas. 480 (C.C.D. Me. 1823), Supreme Court Justice Joseph Story, sitting as circuit justice on an admiralty appeal, traced maintenance and cure back through Oléron, Wisby and the Hanseatic laws. He wrote that seamen "are emphatically the wards of the admiralty": often poor and far from home, they would "suffer the accumulated evils of disease, and poverty" unless the ship paid for their care. Making the owner pay, he reasoned, gives the owner a stake in the crew's safety and health.

The Osceola (1903): a gap in the law. In The Osceola, 189 U.S. 158 (1903), the Supreme Court summed up a seaman's rights: maintenance and cure for any illness or injury in the ship's service; compensation for injuries caused by an unseaworthy ship; but no recovery for the negligence of the master or fellow crew. A sailor hurt because an officer gave a careless order could get room, board and medical care, nothing more.

The Jones Act (1920). Congress closed that gap. Section 33 of the Merchant Marine Act of 1920, known as the Jones Act after Senator Wesley Jones of Washington, gave seamen the right to sue their employer for negligence, before a jury, borrowing the protective rules Congress had written for railroad workers in the Federal Employers' Liability Act. It is now at 46 U.S.C. § 30104.

  • 6th century AD — Milestone: Rhodian law of jettison in Justinian's Digest; Why it matters to you: Shared loss at sea; the law "is lord of the sea"
  • c. 930–1100 — Milestone: Norway's Gulathing law and the levy-ship system; Why it matters to you: Organized crews and ships by law
  • Late 1100s — Milestone: Rolls of Oléron, arts. 6–7; Why it matters to you: First written rule: the ship pays to cure and keep an injured or sick sailor
  • 1276 — Milestone: Norway's Town Law and the seafarers' law that accompanied it; Why it matters to you: Written law for trading voyages
  • Later Middle Ages — Milestone: Laws of Wisby; Hanseatic ordinances; Why it matters to you: The care rule spreads across Northern Europe
  • 1494 — Milestone: Consolato del Mare printed in Barcelona; Why it matters to you: Mediterranean sea customs
  • 1823 — Milestone: Harden v. Gordon (Justice Story); Why it matters to you: Leading early American statement of maintenance and cure; seamen as "wards of the admiralty"
  • 1903 — Milestone: The Osceola; Why it matters to you: Unseaworthiness recognized; no claim for crew negligence
  • 1920 — Milestone: Jones Act; Why it matters to you: Right to sue the employer for negligence, with a jury
  • 2009 — Milestone: Atlantic Sounding Co. v. Townsend; Why it matters to you: Punitive damages when a company willfully refuses maintenance and cure

The leading American treatise on these rights, Norris's The Law of Seamen (now edited by Robert Force), traces this history in depth; this guide follows its broad organization.

3. Are you a seaman?

Everything in this guide depends on one question: are you a "seaman"? The word covers far more than sailors on ocean ships. Deckhands, engineers, cooks, tankermen, ferry crews, tug and barge crews, dredge workers and commercial fishermen can all qualify.

The Supreme Court's two-part test (Chandris, Inc. v. Latsis, 515 U.S. 347 (1995)):

  1. Your work contributes to the function of a vessel or the accomplishment of its mission. You do not have to navigate or steer; you must be doing the ship's work (McDermott International, Inc. v. Wilander, 498 U.S. 337 (1991)).
  2. You have a connection to a vessel in navigation (or a fleet of vessels) that is substantial in both duration and nature.

The 30% rule of thumb. The Court said "a worker who spends less than about 30 percent of his time in the service of a vessel in navigation should not qualify as a seaman," adding that this is "no more than a guideline" (Chandris). Keep records of your time aboard: logs, timesheets, dispatch slips.

What is a vessel? Any watercraft "practically capable of maritime transportation", including dredges, barges, work boats and floating cranes (Stewart v. Dutra Construction Co., 543 U.S. 481 (2005)). A structure that a reasonable observer would not see as designed to carry people or things on water, such as a floating home, is not a vessel (Lozman v. City of Riviera Beach, 568 U.S. 115 (2013)).

A fleet means vessels under common ownership or control. A worker hired for one-off jobs on different owners' boats usually is not a seaman (Harbor Tug & Barge Co. v. Papai, 520 U.S. 548 (1997), reversing the Ninth Circuit).

Gray areas. A ship-repair worker whose job is listed in the Longshore Act can still be a seaman; whether he is, is usually a question for the jury (Southwest Marine, Inc. v. Gizoni, 502 U.S. 81 (1991), a San Diego case). Taking longshore benefits does not by itself bar a later Jones Act claim. Courts in the Fifth Circuit (Texas and Louisiana) now ask extra questions about whether the work is sea-based (Sanchez v. Smart Fabricators of Texas, L.L.C., 997 F.3d 564 (5th Cir. 2021) (en banc)); that decision does not bind California courts.

Not a seaman? If you load, unload, build or repair ships from the dock or shipyard, the Longshore Act is likely your law. See our Longshore guide. Getting this right early matters, because the benefits, deadlines and courts differ.

4. Your three rights at a glance

An injured or ill seaman usually has three separate claims against the employer or vessel owner. You can bring them together, and each covers something the others do not.

  • Source — Maintenance and cure: Centuries-old maritime law; Unseaworthiness: General maritime law; Jones Act negligence: Federal statute, 46 U.S.C. § 30104
  • Must anyone be at fault? — Maintenance and cure: No; Unseaworthiness: No negligence needed, but the vessel, gear or crew must have been unfit; Jones Act negligence: Yes, but the employer's negligence need only play "any part, even the slightest"
  • What it pays — Maintenance and cure: Daily living money (maintenance), medical care (cure), and unearned wages; Unseaworthiness: Full damages: lost wages and earning capacity, medical costs, pain and suffering; Jones Act negligence: Full damages: lost wages and earning capacity, medical costs, pain and suffering
  • Does your own fault reduce it? — Maintenance and cure: No (only willful misconduct defeats it); Unseaworthiness: Yes, in proportion; Jones Act negligence: Yes, in proportion, except where a safety statute was broken
  • When it ends — Maintenance and cure: At maximum medical improvement; Unseaworthiness: When the case is resolved; Jones Act negligence: When the case is resolved
  • Punitive damages? — Maintenance and cure: Yes, if the company willfully refuses to pay; Unseaworthiness: No; Jones Act negligence: No
  • Chapter — Maintenance and cure: 5–7; Unseaworthiness: 8; Jones Act negligence: 9

Maintenance and cure gets you through recovery. Unseaworthiness and Jones Act negligence are how you are paid for the injury itself.

5. Maintenance: daily living money, and why it can be small

Maintenance is a daily payment for your basic living costs (food and lodging) while you recover ashore from an injury or illness that happened in the ship's service. It is owed whether or not anyone was at fault, from the day you leave the vessel until you reach maximum medical improvement.

What it covers. The reasonable cost of food, lodging and transportation to and from medical care (Ninth Circuit Model Civil Jury Instructions, ch. 7). Lodging can include your rent or mortgage and utilities. It is meant to match what the ship would have provided: room and board, not your wages. No maintenance is owed for days you are in the hospital, because the hospital feeds and houses you.

Why the amount can be small. For decades, union contracts set maintenance at $8 a day, a figure courts applied from the late 1940s into the 1970s (Ammar v. United States, 342 F.3d 133 (2d Cir. 2003)). Many contracts still set low rates; courts have enforced contract rates as low as $8 a day (Gardiner, below) and $15 a day (Frederick v. Kirby Tankships, Inc., 205 F.3d 1277 (11th Cir. 2000)).

Union seamen in California. The Ninth Circuit enforces the rate in a union contract, even when it is too low to live on. In Gardiner v. Sea-Land Service, Inc., 786 F.2d 943 (9th Cir. 1986), the court enforced an $8-a-day contract rate although the trial judge had found $8 inadequate for food and lodging in the San Francisco Bay Area, reasoning that the rate is one part of a bargained package of wages and benefits. Most federal appeals courts that have ruled agree; the Third Circuit is the exception (Barnes v. Andover Co., 900 F.2d 630 (3d Cir. 1990), refused to bind a seaman who proved higher costs), but Gardiner binds federal courts in California.

Non-union seamen: your real costs. If no union contract sets the rate, you are owed your actual, reasonable costs. The Ninth Circuit uses a burden-shifting test (Barnes v. Sea Hawaii Rafting, LLC, 889 F.3d 517 (9th Cir. 2018)):

  1. You show your actual food and lodging expenses. Your burden is light; receipts, a lease, utility bills and your own testimony can do it.
  2. The burden then shifts to the employer to prove your expenses are unreasonable.

In Barnes, the seaman showed $68 a day, the employer's own evidence showed $24 to $34, and the court ordered at least $34 a day while the case went on. In the Fifth Circuit, Hall v. Noble Drilling (U.S.) Inc., 242 F.3d 582 (5th Cir. 2001), the trial court awarded about $31 a day in place of the $21 the company had paid, and the appeals court affirmed.

Living with family. Maintenance covers your costs, not your family's. Courts look only at your own share of costs, but if you are responsible for the whole rent or mortgage and the cost is reasonable, courts have allowed the full housing cost (Hall). Ninth Circuit instructions cap maintenance at what a seaman living alone in your area would spend.

Unearned wages. On top of maintenance, you are owed the wages you would have earned through the end of the voyage or the contract period you signed on for, or until maximum cure if that comes sooner (Berg v. Fourth Shipmor Associates, 82 F.3d 307 (9th Cir. 1996)). That can include accumulated time off you would have earned (Lipscomb v. Foss Maritime Co., 83 F.3d 1106 (9th Cir. 1996)).

Tips: keep every rent receipt, utility bill and grocery receipt; tell your lawyer what your real costs are; and do not assume the company's daily figure is right. Full wage replacement and pain and suffering come from the Jones Act and unseaworthiness claims (Chapters 8–9), not from maintenance.

6. Cure: medical care, how long it lasts, and choosing your doctor

Cure is your employer's duty to pay for the medical care you need for an injury or illness that arose in the service of the ship: doctors, hospital, surgery, therapy, medicine and medical equipment. Like maintenance, it does not depend on anyone's fault.

It covers more than on-the-job accidents. Illnesses that show up while you are in the ship's service count, and so do injuries on authorized shore leave and while traveling to or from the vessel (Aguilar v. Standard Oil Co. of New Jersey, 318 U.S. 724 (1943)). Your own carelessness does not cut it off; in Warren v. United States, 340 U.S. 523 (1951), a seaman who fell at a dance hall on shore leave still recovered. Only willful misbehavior, such as a fight you started or serious intoxication, defeats it.

How long it lasts: until maximum medical improvement. Cure and maintenance continue until you reach "maximum cure": your doctor says further treatment will not improve your condition (Farrell v. United States, 336 U.S. 511 (1949)). They do not continue for life just because a condition is permanent, and they cannot be paid in advance as a lump sum for life (Calmar Steamship Corp. v. Taylor, 303 U.S. 525 (1938)). But the duty continues until a medical diagnosis actually establishes maximum cure, even if the condition was permanent all along (Vella v. Ford Motor Co., 421 U.S. 1 (1975)). Treatment that only relieves pain, without improving your condition, generally does not extend cure; ask your lawyer about your situation.

Can you choose your own doctor? The honest answer is: usually, but it is less clear-cut than under the Longshore Act.

  • Until 1981, the government ran free Public Health Service hospitals for seamen. Courts held that an employer could meet its duty by sending a seaman there, and a seaman who refused that free care without good reason could not charge the employer for private care (Kossick v. United Fruit Co., 365 U.S. 731 (1961)). Congress closed those hospitals in 1981.
  • Since then, the leading cases hold that when the employer offers a particular private doctor, you do not lose cure just by choosing a different private doctor (Caulfield v. AC & D Marine, Inc., 633 F.2d 1129 (5th Cir. 1981)). If the care offered is inadequate, you may choose your own physician, and the employer must pay unless it proves your doctor is more expensive than a qualified doctor it prefers or is providing unnecessary treatment (Rodriguez Alvarez v. Bahama Cruise Line, Inc., 898 F.2d 312 (2d Cir. 1990)).
  • We are aware of no published Ninth Circuit decision settling this question, so courts here look to these cases.

In practice: see your own doctor; tell the employer in writing who is treating you and send the bills and reports; attend a company medical exam if asked, but remember that doctor examines you, not treats you; and never stop treatment just because the company stops paying. Your health insurance or Medi-Cal can bridge the gap while your lawyer pursues the employer.

Cure also pays for travel to medical care, and failing to provide cure can itself be a basis for a Jones Act claim if it makes your condition worse (Cortes v. Baltimore Insular Line, Inc., 287 U.S. 367 (1932)).

7. When the company won't pay: attorney's fees and punitive damages

Employers sometimes stall, pay too little or cut off maintenance and cure. The law gives you real leverage when they do.

  • Back pay. You can sue for unpaid maintenance and cure, and courts can order the employer to start paying while the rest of the case goes on (in Barnes v. Sea Hawaii Rafting the Ninth Circuit ordered at least $34 a day pending trial).
  • Damages for harm caused. If the failure to provide care made your condition worse, you can recover for that harm (Cortes).
  • Attorney's fees. When an employer's refusal is "callous," "willful and persistent," you can recover the lawyer's fees you spent getting paid (Vaughan v. Atkinson, 369 U.S. 527 (1962)).
  • Punitive damages. The Supreme Court held that a seaman may pursue punitive damages for an employer's willful failure to pay maintenance and cure (Atlantic Sounding Co. v. Townsend, 557 U.S. 404 (2009)). This is the only one of the three claims that can carry punitive damages.

What counts as willful? Ignoring a claim, cutting off payments without a medical basis, refusing to investigate, or paying a rate the company knows is too low can all be evidence. Keep every letter, email and denial, and note the dates of every request.

The "concealment" defense. An employer can refuse maintenance and cure if you intentionally lied about or hid a medical condition when it asked during hiring, the condition was material to the hiring decision, and it is connected to the new injury (McCorpen v. Central Gulf Steamship Corp., 396 F.2d 547 (5th Cir. 1968); in the Ninth Circuit, Tawada v. United States, 162 F.2d 615 (9th Cir. 1947)). If you were not asked, you generally need not disclose a condition unless you had reason to believe the employer would consider it important. Always answer pre-employment medical questions truthfully.

8. Unseaworthiness: when the vessel, gear or crew is not reasonably fit

A vessel owner has an absolute duty to provide a seaworthy vessel: a vessel and equipment "reasonably fit for their intended use" (Mitchell v. Trawler Racer, Inc., 362 U.S. 539 (1960)). If an unseaworthy condition caused your injury, the owner is liable even if it did not know about the problem and was not careless.

What it is not. The owner does not have to provide an accident-free ship. "The standard is not perfection, but reasonable fitness" (Mitchell).

Common examples:

  • Slippery decks from oil, grease, ice or fish slime; missing non-skid surfaces
  • Broken, worn or missing equipment: winches, lines, ladders, railings, hatch covers, lights
  • Unsafe work methods ordered as routine on board
  • Not enough crew for the job, or a crew member who is unfit or dangerous
  • Missing or defective safety gear

The duty cannot be passed off. The owner is responsible even if the condition was created by an officer or crew member (Mahnich v. Southern Steamship Co., 321 U.S. 96 (1944)). But a single, isolated careless act by a crewmate, such as one wrong order in an otherwise sound operation, is usually treated as negligence rather than unseaworthiness (Usner v. Luckenbach Overseas Corp., 400 U.S. 494 (1971)). That case goes under the Jones Act instead (Chapter 9).

Who can claim it. Seamen. Longshore workers lost this claim in 1972 and sue vessels for negligence instead (see our Longshore guide).

Limits. Punitive damages are not available for unseaworthiness (Dutra Group v. Batterton, 588 U.S. 358 (2019), a case from the Ninth Circuit). Your own fault reduces the award in proportion (Chapter 10).

Proof matters. Photos of the condition, maintenance logs, prior complaints and crew testimony win these claims. Ask crewmates what they saw before they ship out.

9. Jones Act negligence: "any part, even the slightest"

The Jones Act lets a seaman sue his employer, before a jury, when the employer's negligence caused his injury (46 U.S.C. § 30104). It borrows the worker-friendly rules of the Federal Employers' Liability Act for railroad workers (45 U.S.C. §§ 51–60).

A low bar for causation. You win if the employer's negligence "played any part, even the slightest, in producing the injury" (Rogers v. Missouri Pacific Railroad Co., 352 U.S. 500 (1957)). The Supreme Court applied the same rule to a ship's baker who cut his hand chipping rock-hard ice cream with a butcher knife because he was not given a proper tool, and stressed the jury's "pre-eminent role in these Jones Act cases" (Ferguson v. Moore-McCormack Lines, Inc., 352 U.S. 521 (1957)). The Ninth Circuit says "even the slightest negligence is sufficient" (Havens v. F/T Polar Mist, 996 F.2d 215 (9th Cir. 1993)).

What negligence looks like: inadequate training or supervision; too few crew; unsafe orders; working in bad weather without precautions; ignoring a known hazard; failing to provide safe equipment or a safe place to work; fellow crew members' careless acts; failing to get you prompt medical care.

Safety violations. If the employer broke a safety statute or Coast Guard regulation and that contributed to your injury, liability follows even without other proof of negligence (Kernan v. American Dredging Co., 355 U.S. 426 (1958)). If the employer violated a safety statute, your own fault cannot reduce the award (45 U.S.C. § 53); whether a regulation violation has the same effect is unsettled in the Ninth Circuit (Kopczynski v. The Jacqueline, 742 F.2d 555 (9th Cir. 1984)).

You did not "assume the risk." A company cannot defend by saying the job was dangerous and you knew it, or that you chose to use a defective tool (Socony-Vacuum Oil Co. v. Smith, 305 U.S. 424 (1939); 45 U.S.C. § 54). That choice can still reduce your damages as comparative fault (Chapter 10).

Who is the defendant? Your employer, which is usually but not always the vessel owner. Unseaworthiness claims go against the owner or operator of the vessel. Your lawyer brings both together.

10. Your own mistakes, comparative fault and safety rules

Being partly at fault does not end your case.

  • Comparative fault. If you were partly careless, your damages for negligence and unseaworthiness are reduced by your share. A jury that finds you 20% at fault reduces a $500,000 verdict to $400,000 (45 U.S.C. § 53).
  • The standard for you is ordinary care. You are expected to act as a reasonably careful seaman would in the same situation; Ninth Circuit jury instructions ask whether you used the care a reasonably prudent person would use under similar circumstances.
  • No reduction when a safety statute was broken by the employer and it contributed to your injury (45 U.S.C. § 53).
  • Maintenance and cure are not reduced for your own fault (Chapter 6).
  • Following orders. If you were hurt carrying out an order, that matters to how fault is weighed. Tell your lawyer exactly who gave which instruction.

11. What a claim can recover, and wrongful death

Under the Jones Act and for unseaworthiness, an injured seaman can recover:

  • Past and future lost wages and lost earning capacity, including overtime and benefits you would have earned
  • Past and future medical expenses not already paid as cure
  • Pain and suffering, physical and mental, including loss of enjoyment of life
  • Maintenance, cure and unearned wages (Chapters 5–6), with attorney's fees and punitive damages if they were willfully withheld (Chapter 7)

What is not available: punitive damages for unseaworthiness (Batterton) or for Jones Act negligence. There is no fixed "settlement calculator"; value depends on the injury, your age and earnings, how long you would have worked at sea, the evidence of fault, and the jury venue.

When a seaman dies. The seaman's personal representative can bring a Jones Act and unseaworthiness wrongful-death claim for the family. Recovery is limited to financial losses, such as the support and services the seaman would have provided; there is no recovery for the family's loss of companionship ("loss of society") (Miles v. Apex Marine Corp., 498 U.S. 19 (1990)). A survival claim can also recover the seaman's own pain and suffering before death. Deaths far offshore can also involve the Death on the High Seas Act. Families should speak with a maritime lawyer quickly, because evidence and deadlines matter.

12. Deadlines, where to file, and traps to avoid

The three-year deadline. A lawsuit for personal injury or death "arising out of a maritime tort must be brought within 3 years after the cause of action arose" (46 U.S.C. § 30106). That covers Jones Act and unseaworthiness claims. Claims against the U.S. government or its vessels have a two-year limit (46 U.S.C. § 30905) and special rules, so get advice early if a government vessel is involved. If you are fired or punished for reporting an injury, a federal complaint must be filed with the Department of Labor within 180 days (46 U.S.C. § 2114).

Where to file. You can sue in state court or federal court, with a jury either way (46 U.S.C. § 30104; the "saving to suitors" clause, 28 U.S.C. § 1333(1)). A Jones Act case filed in state court generally cannot be moved to federal court by the employer (28 U.S.C. § 1445(a), applied through the Jones Act; see Lewis v. Lewis & Clark Marine, Inc., 531 U.S. 438 (2001)). The choice of court is strategic: juries, rules and speed differ.

Traps that cost seamen money:

  • Recorded statements. The adjuster's job is to limit what the company pays. You do not have to give a recorded statement. If you give one, keep it short and accurate, and do not guess about what caused the accident.
  • Releases. Do not sign any release, "receipt" or settlement paperwork for maintenance and cure or your injury claim without a maritime lawyer. Courts look hard at seamen's releases, but undoing one is far harder than not signing it.
  • The company doctor's "fit for duty." A quick release to work can be used to cut off maintenance and cure. Follow your own doctor's advice and get copies of every medical report.
  • Going back too soon. Returning to work before you are ready can hurt your health and your claim. Talk to your doctor and lawyer first.
  • Social media. Photos of you lifting, fishing or traveling will be used against you. Stay off it while your claim is open.
  • Waiting. Witnesses ship out, logs are overwritten, and vessels are repaired. Call early.

13. Common company defenses, and how they are answered

  • "You are not a seaman." — How it is answered: Proof of your time aboard and your role in the vessel's work, under the Chandris test (Chapter 3). If you are not a seaman, the Longshore Act or California comp may apply instead.
  • "It was your own fault." — How it is answered: Fault only reduces Jones Act and unseaworthiness damages in proportion, and not at all when a safety statute was broken. It does not reduce maintenance and cure (Chapter 10).
  • "You've reached maximum medical improvement." — How it is answered: Maximum cure is a medical question. Your treating doctor's opinion counts, and benefits continue until a diagnosis actually establishes it (Vella).
  • "The union rate is $X a day." — How it is answered: For union seamen in California the contract rate generally controls (Gardiner). For others, your actual reasonable expenses do (Barnes, 2018).
  • "You hid a prior condition." — How it is answered: The defense requires intentional concealment of a material fact the company asked about, connected to the new injury (McCorpen; Tawada).
  • "The vessel was fine; it was a one-time mistake." — How it is answered: That may defeat unseaworthiness (Usner) but not Jones Act negligence, which needs only slight fault (Rogers).
  • "You waited too long." — How it is answered: You have three years for most claims (§ 30106). Maintenance and cure can be pursued right away.
  • "You signed a release." — How it is answered: Seamen's releases are closely reviewed; a lawyer can assess whether it holds.

14. Seamen in the Bay Area and on the West Coast

You do not have to sail the open ocean to be a Jones Act seaman. In the Bay Area and Northern California, seamen include:

  • Ferry crews: deckhands, engineers and captains on Bay passenger ferries
  • Tug and barge crews: harbor tugs that dock container ships at Oakland and Richmond, and barge and tanker-escort crews in the Bay and the Delta
  • Dredge and marine construction crews aboard dredges, crane barges and work boats, which courts treat as vessels (Stewart v. Dutra Construction Co., a Massachusetts dredge case)
  • Commercial fishermen working out of the Bay Area and coastal harbors
  • Crew on research vessels, excursion boats and sport-fishing boats
  • Merchant mariners on oceangoing ships calling at Bay ports

West Coast cases have shaped this law. Southwest Marine v. Gizoni came from a San Diego shipyard, Harbor Tug & Barge v. Papai from the Ninth Circuit, Dutra Group v. Batterton and Barnes v. Sea Hawaii Rafting through the Ninth Circuit, and Gardiner v. Sea-Land Service addressed Bay Area living costs.

Where cases are heard. Federal courts in San Francisco, Oakland and San Jose (Northern District of California), and California superior courts, with appeals to the Ninth Circuit.

Hablamos español. Many Bay Area deckhands, fishermen and marine workers prefer Spanish. Daniel Weltin's office explains every step in Spanish.

15. Landmark cases at a glance

  • Harden v. Gordon, 11 F. Cas. 480 (C.C.D. Me.) — Year: 1823; What it means for you: Seamen are "wards of the admiralty"; leading early American statement of maintenance and cure
  • The Osceola, 189 U.S. 158 — Year: 1903; What it means for you: Maintenance and cure regardless of fault; damages for unseaworthiness
  • Cortes v. Baltimore Insular Line, 287 U.S. 367 — Year: 1932; What it means for you: Failing to provide care can be Jones Act negligence
  • Calmar S.S. Corp. v. Taylor, 303 U.S. 525 — Year: 1938; What it means for you: No lump sum of maintenance and cure for life
  • Socony-Vacuum Oil Co. v. Smith, 305 U.S. 424 — Year: 1939; What it means for you: No "assumption of risk" defense
  • Aguilar v. Standard Oil Co. of N.J., 318 U.S. 724 — Year: 1943; What it means for you: Covers shore leave and travel to and from the ship
  • Mahnich v. Southern S.S. Co., 321 U.S. 96 — Year: 1944; What it means for you: Owner liable for unseaworthiness even if crew caused the condition
  • Farrell v. United States, 336 U.S. 511 — Year: 1949; What it means for you: Maintenance and cure last until maximum cure
  • Warren v. United States, 340 U.S. 523 — Year: 1951; What it means for you: Your own carelessness does not defeat maintenance and cure
  • Rogers v. Missouri Pacific R.R., 352 U.S. 500 — Year: 1957; What it means for you: Negligence playing "any part, even the slightest" is enough
  • Ferguson v. Moore-McCormack Lines, 352 U.S. 521 — Year: 1957; What it means for you: Applies that rule to seamen; juries decide
  • Kernan v. American Dredging Co., 355 U.S. 426 — Year: 1958; What it means for you: Liability for a safety-rule violation without other negligence
  • Mitchell v. Trawler Racer, Inc., 362 U.S. 539 — Year: 1960; What it means for you: Owner must provide a vessel "reasonably fit"; no negligence needed
  • Kossick v. United Fruit Co., 365 U.S. 731 — Year: 1961; What it means for you: Refusing free public-hospital care without just cause could limit cure; promises about care are governed by maritime law
  • Vaughan v. Atkinson, 369 U.S. 527 — Year: 1962; What it means for you: Attorney's fees when an employer willfully refuses to pay
  • Usner v. Luckenbach Overseas Corp., 400 U.S. 494 — Year: 1971; What it means for you: One isolated careless act is not unseaworthiness
  • Vella v. Ford Motor Co., 421 U.S. 1 — Year: 1975; What it means for you: Benefits continue until maximum cure is medically established
  • Gardiner v. Sea-Land Service, 786 F.2d 943 (9th Cir.) — Year: 1986; What it means for you: Union-contract maintenance rate enforced, even at $8 a day
  • Miles v. Apex Marine Corp., 498 U.S. 19 — Year: 1990; What it means for you: Wrongful death recovery limited to financial loss
  • McDermott Int'l v. Wilander, 498 U.S. 337 — Year: 1991; What it means for you: A seaman need not navigate; he must do the ship's work
  • Southwest Marine v. Gizoni, 502 U.S. 81 — Year: 1991; What it means for you: A ship-repair worker can be a seaman; usually a jury question
  • Chandris, Inc. v. Latsis, 515 U.S. 347 — Year: 1995; What it means for you: Two-part seaman test; the 30% rule of thumb
  • Harbor Tug & Barge Co. v. Papai, 520 U.S. 548 — Year: 1997; What it means for you: A "fleet" needs common ownership or control
  • Lewis v. Lewis & Clark Marine, 531 U.S. 438 — Year: 2001; What it means for you: Seamen may sue in state court
  • Stewart v. Dutra Construction Co., 543 U.S. 481 — Year: 2005; What it means for you: A dredge is a vessel
  • Atlantic Sounding Co. v. Townsend, 557 U.S. 404 — Year: 2009; What it means for you: Punitive damages for willful failure to pay maintenance and cure
  • Lozman v. City of Riviera Beach, 568 U.S. 115 — Year: 2013; What it means for you: A floating home is not a vessel
  • Barnes v. Sea Hawaii Rafting, 889 F.3d 517 (9th Cir.) — Year: 2018; What it means for you: Non-union maintenance based on actual reasonable costs
  • Dutra Group v. Batterton, 588 U.S. 358 — Year: 2019; What it means for you: No punitive damages for unseaworthiness

16. Frequently asked questions

What does the Jones Act cover?

It lets a seaman injured on the job sue his employer for negligence, before a jury, and recover lost wages, medical costs and pain and suffering (46 U.S.C. § 30104). Seamen also have maintenance and cure and unseaworthiness claims under general maritime law.

Do I count as a Jones Act seaman if I work on a ferry or tugboat in the Bay Area?

Usually yes, if you are crew who contributes to the vessel's work and spend a substantial part of your time aboard, about 30% or more as a rule of thumb (Chapter 3).

What is maintenance and cure, and how much should I be paid per day?

Maintenance is daily money for food and lodging; cure is medical care. For union seamen in California the contract rate usually controls, even if low. Non-union seamen are owed their actual reasonable costs, and courts have ordered $30 to $34 a day or more (Chapter 5).

My employer stopped paying maintenance and cure. What can I do?

You can sue to restart it, recover what is owed, and, if the refusal was willful, recover attorney's fees and punitive damages (Chapter 7).

Can I choose my own doctor?

Generally yes. Courts have held that choosing a different private doctor does not forfeit cure, but the employer can contest unreasonable costs. We know of no Ninth Circuit decision settling it (Chapter 6).

What is the difference between a Jones Act claim and an unseaworthiness claim?

The Jones Act requires some employer negligence, however slight. Unseaworthiness requires no negligence, but the vessel, gear or crew must have been unfit (Chapters 8–9).

How long do I have to file?

Three years for most seamen's injury lawsuits (46 U.S.C. § 30106); shorter for some government vessels (Chapter 12).

How much are Jones Act settlements worth?

There is no fixed amount or reliable calculator. Value depends on your injury, wages, age, the evidence of fault and the court (Chapter 11).

Can I be fired for filing a claim?

Federal law forbids firing or discriminating against a seaman for reporting a work injury (46 U.S.C. § 2114). A complaint must be filed with the U.S. Department of Labor within 180 days, far sooner than the three-year injury deadline, so act quickly.

Am I covered by the Jones Act or the Longshore Act?

Crew members are covered by the Jones Act; dock and shipyard workers usually by the Longshore Act. See our Longshore guide.

Where did maintenance and cure come from?

Medieval sea codes, especially the Rolls of Oléron in the late 1100s, required ships to care for injured and sick sailors; Justice Story's 1823 opinion in Harden v. Gordon became the leading early American statement of the rule (Chapter 2).

17. Glossary, how we help, and sources

Glossary

  • Cure: the employer's duty to pay for medical care.
  • Jones Act: the 1920 law letting seamen sue their employers for negligence (46 U.S.C. § 30104).
  • Maintenance: daily payments for food and lodging while you recover.
  • Maximum medical improvement (maximum cure): when further treatment will not improve your condition.
  • Seaman: a worker who contributes to a vessel's work and has a substantial connection to a vessel in navigation.
  • Unearned wages: pay you would have earned through the end of the voyage or contract period.
  • Unseaworthiness: a vessel, its equipment or crew not reasonably fit for their intended use.
  • Vessel: a watercraft practically capable of carrying people or things on water.

How Daniel Weltin helps

Daniel Weltin represents injured seamen, longshore workers and working families from his office at 777 Davis Street, Suite 146, San Leandro, in English and Spanish. He can tell you whether you are a seaman, push for full maintenance and cure now, and pursue your Jones Act and unseaworthiness claims.

Call (510) 856-4421 for a free, confidential consultation. Hablamos español.

Sources

Reviewed by Daniel Weltin, attorney at law. Updated November 2026. This guide is general information, not legal advice for your situation. Call for advice about your case. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

‍

Free guides

More guides for injured workers

Blog Cover
Longshore Act (LHWCA) Benefits: The Complete Guide

Hurt on the docks? Situs and status, average weekly wage, choosing your doctor, permanent disability, COLAs, settlements and deadlines.

icon
Blog Cover
Replaced by H-1B workers? Your rights as a U.S. worker in Silicon Valley

Fired or passed over because your employer prefers H-1B or other visa workers? Federal and California law protect U.S. citizens. Your rights and deadlines.

icon
Blog Cover
California workers' comp rights regardless of immigration status

In California, injured workers can get workers' comp no matter their immigration status. Here are your rights and what to do after a work injury.

icon